Forgiveness
Not long after our friends were forced to leave the Community—what they described as akin to Jonah being tossed off the ship—John and I realized our time was also coming to end. Our creative worship services were drawing people from outside our initial circle, not all of whom shared the values of Sojourners that drove our initial formation. Some in the elders group felt we needed to convince everyone to accept principles like pacifism, organic food, low-income living, women in leadership, or else the witness of our church would be watered down. John and I disagreed and thought it had a cultish tinge. We trusted that if God brought new people to our group, listening to their ideas could help us learn and grow.
One day an astonishing thing happened while I was meeting with my spiritual director, a sister from the local Catholic Church. Recognizing my growing discontent, she had assigned me Bible passages to read and write about, putting myself into the story. I accumulated a whole notebook full of questions.
Moments after she commented that John and I seemed restless and perhaps God had a change in store for us, John came home in the middle of the day and announced, “A friend just called and offered me a job in Ann Arbor!” I was shocked and amazed but most of all I couldn’t stop smiling. Talking about leaving Community was taboo. We had a wide front door, but no exit.
That night John and I came down with a terrible flu. Our oldest son took over feeding his siblings while we lay in bed with high fevers. This went on for ten days during which time the job offer and the possibility of moving back to Ann Arbor – my home town and the place where we had met in college – captured our imaginations.
After we recovered I read my journal and saw my questions being resolved. Those ten days convinced us to follow this opportunity; no one could change our minds. Shortly afterwards we left. A few months later someone from Menominee called and shared disturbing news about a serious failure of the remaining original couple who had to pack up and leave immediately.
Ten intense years of living in Community, plus years together in seminary had created extraordinary bonds between us. I struggled to accept, to understand, and to forgive. One sleepless night I got out of bed and wrote this song.
Forgiveness is a complicated process. We do it for ourselves as well as for others. Jesus is clear when, after teaching the Lord’s Prayer to his disciples, he says, “For if you forgive others when they sin against you, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. But if you do not forgive others their sins, your Father will not forgive your sins.” Matthew 6:14.
Forgiveness is not optional for those who follow Christ.
